In the essay “Me Talk Pretty One Day,” David Sedaris writes
about his school in France and the difficulties of learning the language. He
writes very well, but does not follow all of the guidelines for college
writing. Sedaris uses plain style like The
Nuts and Bolts of College Writing suggests, but he doesn’t focus on a main thesis for the paper.
The language in “Me Talk Pretty One Day” is easy to understand,
like Nuts and Bolts suggests. In the
essay, Sedaris goes off to school to learn French, but faces many difficulties.
He notices improvement by the end of the essay, and hopes that one day, he will
master French. Even though in the essay Sedaris tries to prove to his teacher
that he is smart, he doesn’t try to seem smart with his language for the essay.
Therefore, the ideas in the essay aren’t clouded. He states plainly that “I’ve
moved to Paris with hopes of learning the language,” and he also describes his
teacher by comparing her to a wild animal so that the readers understand his
challenges. The clear language allows the reader to understand the essay and experience
all the things that happened in the story.
Since “Me Talk Pretty One Day” isn’t a college essay, it
doesn’t follow all of the rules in Nuts
and Bolts, like talking in first person and not sticking to a thesis. The
point of the essay is to tell a story about Sedaris’s experience in France at
school, not to prove a claim. So, it only makes sense to write the essay in
first person. He also wants to entertain the audience more than a college essay
would. Sedaris describes the school and the city in more detail, and explains
how many different nationalities that are much younger than him are gathered to
learn. This adds more depth to the story, since the readers now know that
Sedaris has to perform at a very high level to keep up with the other students
even before the teacher is introduced. This style may not be fitting for a
college essay, but Sedaris uses it well to tell a personal story.
The Nuts and Bolts of college writing provides very useful
writing tips that can also be used in other types of writing. However, it is
okay to bend the rules when the essay isn’t meant to persuade the audience or
prove a point.
I'd like to see a bit more focus here on the ways in which Sedaris DOES follow Harvey's advice--there are plenty!
ReplyDelete